Cube and weigh out your butter and leave to soften. A smaller surface area will soften quicker and be easier to mix with. See Photo 1 below. I like to cut them about 1cm, ⅓″ size. If you are in a hurry, or forget to take it out on time, here’s a hack I tried. Soften Butter In About 12 Minutes. Weigh out and add the sugar to the soft butter and mix by machine or hand for a few minutes until very creamy, smooth and soft and also paler in colour. This is known as ‘creaming the butter & sugar’ together. See Photo 1 above for how it should look or check out the video. It is the best method for incorporating air into the batter to produce a light airy cake.
Next add in the eggs one at a time, with the mixer on low to medium speed, just briefly until mixed through, also known as ‘amalgamated’ or you might hear or read the word ‘emulsified’. (See Photo 2 below). To emulsify means to combine two liquids that normally do not combine so easily, such as vinegar & oil. So at this stage of the recipe, we are trying to emulsify the egg with the butter. As a result, sometimes the eggs may make the batter look a little curdled or split. If this happens just add 2 dessert spoons of your flour while mixing in the eggs. But don’t worry about it, it will bake out fine. You don’t even need to add the flour like that, as you will be adding in soon.
For even more height in the sponge, you can whisk the eggs first since this activates the protein in the egg, and protein provides structure. Now mix in the vanilla extract just till combined. See Photo 2 above.
Now sieve in the flour (and baking powder is using plain/A.P. flour), on top of the batter. You can also sieve & mix into a separate bowl & then re-sieve into the batter if you like. See Photo 3 above. Proceed to mix on low to start, and add in th emilk. Then mix on medium speed until all incorporated into a smooth thick batter. Only mix until no flour is seen, as you don’t want to over-mix it and knock out the air you incorporated. If you can hold the sieve higher up from the bowl, this too will incorporate more air into the batter. Sieving twice gets even more air into the batter too. See Photo 4 below.
Heat up the oven to 180c/160c Fan oven/350f/Gas Mark 4.
Now in a small bowl add about 1 tsp water to the jam/jelly and mix to combine. Just enough to thin slightly, but will depend on how thick and jelly-like your jam is. See the video for the consistency.
Oil or grease your baking tins well, paying particular attention to the sides. Place a circular piece of baking/parchment paper on the bottom of the tin. I recommend this greasing/lining paste recipe by Great British Bake Off winner Nancy Birtwhistle. Alternatively, you can use a Quick Release of Cooking/Baking spray (such as FryLight spray). Use pre-cut or make your own paper circles to line the bottom. Cut paper the width of the tin & then keep folding in half, till you get a pointed cone shape. Then line up with the centre point of the tin and cut off the excess. Then simply unfold and if too big, fold again & trim off slightly. Then just position in place. See Photo 5 above & Photo 6 below. Or watch my video on how to fold paper circles to fit a cake tin. Add about 7 individual teaspoons of the jam to the top of the batter, as per the first row of pics in Photo 7 below. Then use a baking spatula to gently lift the batter from the bottom of the bowl, and fold over the top of the jam. No beating of the batter, but rather a gentle folding over motion. Then add in 3 or 4 more drops of the jam to the batter and fold in gently again. It is ok to have some streaks of the jam through the batter as well as some larger areas of jam. Just don't thoroughly mix the jam through. See Photo 7 below. (Note you should have a little of the jam left over).
Now spoon the batter evenly between the two tins and smooth out. Using a small spoon, drop spoonful’s of the reserved jam/jelly over the top of the cake batter. See video or Photo 8 below. You can use a cocktail stick/tooth pick to make gentle swirls in the top of the batter if you like. Tap the tins a few times on the counter/worktop to expel any trapped air.
Place the 2 tins in the middle shelf of the oven and bake for about 20 – 25 minutes. If your oven doesn't bake evenly, you can turn the turns, after the half-way mark (and they won't deflate). So wait till at least 13 minutes. Start to check if the cake is done from about the 19 minute mark. They should be a golden colour, but you want to make sure they are fully cooked, so using a clean cocktail stick/tooth pick, pierce the stick into the centre of the cake (not into the jam/jelly). If it comes out clean, then the cake is ready. If not, place back in the oven for a two more minutes and check again until done. The cake will be springy to touch and coming away from the sides of the tin. See Photo 9 below. Leave to cool in the tins, on a cooling rack for at least 15 minutes.
Run a palette knife or butter knife around the edges of the cake tin – it may stick where there is jam/jelly. Place a folded clean tea-towel on the cooling rack and turn the tin over and let the cake fall onto the towel. Might need a few taps. Leave for at least 10 minutes before you try to carefully peel the paper off the cakes. If it isn’t coming off easily, leave it to cool more. See Photo 10 below.
TOP TIP – Placing cakes on the tea towel means there are no rack marks left on the cake. If you intend to decorate on top, this is not important. But if going for the classic look for a Victoria Sandwich cake, you don’t really want lines showing on top. And leaving to cool upside down also results in less of a dome. If you want you can instead turn the cakes out onto a plate, remove the paper and then place the other way up on the cooling rack. Just be careful as the more you turn them at this fragile stage, the more likely a break is (especially with jam in it).