Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies

Chocolate orange sandwich cookies in square, circles and Easter shapes on a pale blue background with flowers and easter eggs.

Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies

With Gluten Free Or Regular Wheat Flour

By Caro


Perfect For Easter/Spring Cookie Cutters

Here's my Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies, my homemade version of Oreos.  With a firmer buttercream, these cookies can be customized to any season or theme.  Super simple to make too.

Jump to Recipe
Orange buttercream filled chocolate sandwich cookies stacked and one in hand with a bit eout, showing texture.

Can Be Gluten Free

Here’s  my ‘Oreo-style’ cookies, Chocolate & orange sandwich cookies, themed for Easter & Spring and filled with an orange flavoured buttercream.  They can be made with regular flour or Gluten Free flour in exactly the same way.  Just be sure to add the Xanthan Gum if your Gluten Free flour doesn’t contain it.

Orange Flavour & Coloured Filling

I chose to  colour the frosting a pastel orange colour to represent the orange flavouring I used and it went really well with the chocolate cookies.

Chocolate & orange sandwich cookies are super simple to make – you won’t go back to the bought ones!  The  filling is made from clarified butter, (don’t worry, it’s super simple to make in about 10 minutes) and sets very quickly. So ideal for a sandwich cookie, with no filling squashing out. 


Duck, carrot and bunny shaped chocolate cookies on a patterned plate with easter eggs and bunny ornamanet.

Just A Little Ingredient Note

Golden Syrup

A note for US/Canadian bakers, who might not be able to source golden syrup, just use maple syrup, honey or something similar. (You can find recipes on-line to make the golden syrup if you need it). It is not  essential to have the exact syrup for this particular bake. I have made it without it and used maple syrup.  

Check this Gingerbread recipe for where to buy Golden Syrup in America & Canada,

Orange Food Colouring

I also used orange colouring in the form of a paste, and like the brand Sugarflair.  You don’t use as  much as a gel and the colours are very concentrated and vibrant.  So ideally use a paste or gel, rather than the little bottles of liquid – also be careful, as it stains – so please wear gloves! I still managed to get some on my fingers!


Reader’s Pics

These cookies are great for anytime of the year but perfect for the holidays too. The keep their shape nicely if using shaped cookie cutters. Here are Christmas themed ones above, made by my friend Diana.


Stacks of round and square cookies next to a bunny rabbit shaped one.

Join My Facebook Group

Why not also join my Facebook group – Easy Online Baking Lessons, dedicated to this baking lessons website, as well as providing one-on-one support with myself & my team? Be sure to answer all security questions when requesting to join. Click to join the group.


Share The Love

Please see the sharing options or even printing, at the right/bottom of your screen (bottom of your screen for mobiles, and down the right-hand side on computers). You can even pin this to your own Pinterest page. Alternatively, you can save or print the recipe, via the Recipe Card below, with or without the photos. You could also leave some feedback if you like.


DIFFICULTY LEVEL: easy, with guidance

Rating: 2 out of 5.

RECIPE CARD

Chocolate orange sandwich cookies in square, circles and Easter shapes on a pale blue background with flowers and easter eggs.
Print

Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies – Oreo-style

Here's my Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies, my homemade version of Oreos. With a firmer buttercream, these cookies can be customized to any season or theme. Super simple to make too.
Course Dessert, Snack, Sweet
Cuisine American
Keyword Biscuits, Chocolate, Clarified butter, Cookies, Easter, Easy, Orange, Oreo, Sandwich Cookies
Prep Time 50 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Chilling Dough 1 hour
Total Time 2 hours
Servings 12 cookies+
Author Caro
SAVE RECIPE Share on Facebook

Equipment

  • Scales or measuring cups
  • Measuring Spoons
  • Stand or hand-held mixer (or by hand with a mixing bowl)
  • Other mixing bowl for dry ingredients
  • Orange Food Colouring (preferably paste or gel), see below)
  • Baking trays/sheets x 2 or 3
  • Baking paper/parchment
  • Rolling Pin
  • Small bowl of flour for dipping
  • Cookie Cutters
  • Timer or Phone Timer
  • Cooling rack
  • Small Cooking Pot
  • Sieve (small & fine preferably) (small & fine preferably)
  • Pastry bag (optional) or spoon & palette knife

Ingredients

For The Cookie Dough

  • 113 grams Butter, unsalted, cubed & softened (½ cup, 1 stick, 4 oz)
  • 100 grams Granulated Sugar (½ cup, 3½ oz)
  • 3 tbsp Golden Syrup * (see notes)
  • ½ tsp Bicarbonate of Soda (Baking Soda)
  • tsp Salt
  • 33 grams Cocoa Powder (¼ cup, 1 oz, 4½ tbsp)
  • 172 grams Plain Flour (1⅓ cup, 6 oz, All Purpose) OR – Plain/All Purpose Gluten Free flour option, plus the addition of ⅜ tsp Xanthan Gum

For The Filling:

  • 128 grams Butter unsalted & roughly cubed (6 oz or ¾ cup)
  • ¾ tsp Vanilla Extract (Learn how to make homemade vanilla extract)
  • Sprinkle of Salt
  • 187 grams Icing Sugar, sieved (1½ cups, 6½ oz Powdered sugar)
  • Orange Food Colouring (paste preferred or gel)
  • Orange Extract (⅛ tsp at a time, to taste, or use orange zest)

Instructions

Prepare The Dough

  • Begin by beating the softened butter with a hand/stand mixer, till smooth (see Photo 1).
    beating butter till smooth collage - photo 1.
  • Next add in the sugar and beat on low to medium speed till incorporated. Then beat further, on high speed, until smoother, paste like and paler in colour (know as 'creaming' the butter and sugar together). See Photo 2.
    Adding sugar to the butter and creaming till smooth collage - photo 2.
  • Add in the Bicarbonate of soda (Baking soda), Salt & Golden Syrup (or alternative) and mix together. Tip for using a spoon with Golden Syrup – oil the spoon first before adding the syrup and it will slide off much easier into your bowl. I use Frylight Cooking spray. See Photo 3.
  • Sieve the flour & cocoa powder over the bowl with the mixture. If making Gluten free ones, be sure to also add the Xanthan Gum too. See Photo 4.
  • Slowly miix through the dry ingredients, until it forms a relatively stiff dough. It will start off as looking like very small brown pebbles. At that stage switch to a baking spatula (or big spoon), and use it to push against the dough until it starts to come together (see the stages in Photo 5 below).
    mixing the dry ingredients in chocolate orange sandwich cookies - photo 5.
  • Test if it's mixed enough by checking with a little dough, if it forms a dough when squashed together in your fingers (see Photo 6). Now, using your hands, knead against the insides of the bowl to form a smooth ball of dough. Then flatten into a disc and place on top of some baking/parchment paper. See Photo 7.
    Testing if the dough is mixed enough - photo 6.
  • Line the baking trays/sheets with baking/parchment paper. If it’s a tray/sheet with no lip, I hold the paper in place with some baking spray or lining paste. I have learned the hard way, that without it, the paper and dough or cookies, can fall off and onto the floor and we don’t want that!
  • On a worktop/counter, place some baking/parchment paper down and a little icing/powdered sugar if needed. Flatten the dough into a disc. Place another sheet of paper on top and you shouldn’t need any flour of even cocoa powder. See Photo 7. Roll out the dough to a 4-5mm (⅙- ⅕ inch) thickness. I used a £2 coin and 1p to get a minimum thickness. Brush excess sugar/cocoa off if you used it.
    Rolling out dough between 2 sheets of paper - photo 7.
  • Dust the cutter in icing/powdered sugar or cocoa and cut out as many cookies as you can, re-rolling the scraps and repeating until all used up, remembering to try to make pairs of cookies to sandwich together. See Photo 8. (Note for some shapes that aren’t symmetrical, for proper ‘pairs’ you should tun over the cutter, or the cut-out dough).
  • Place the cookies on the baking sheets with a gap in-between. See Photo 9. If doing different sizes of cookies, or ones with cut-outs, please be sure to keep similar sizes ones on the same tray and note that there will be a very slight difference in baking times according to the size of cutters you used. See Photo 10.
    Cut out cookies and on the paper lined baking sheet - photo 9.
  • Chill for 1 hr before baking, to ensure they keep their shape and don’t spread out much (but also so that the gluten in the dough & YOU, can rest a bit!) ?

Bake The Cookies

  • Heat up the oven up to 180/160c Fan Oven/350f/Gas Mark 4, before the 1-hour chilling time is up.
  • Bake until firm enough that you can move them slightly by pushing gently with a spatula, They should still be soft. Remember to turn and rotate the baking sheets during cooking if your oven doesn’t bake evenly. With the 3 different shapes I baked them for 8-9 minutes. So I would advise on checking them at about the 7 minute mark (provided they aren’t really small). See Photo 11.
    Balked cookies collage - photo 11.
  • Leave to cool for a few minutes on the tray/sheet, before transferring, paper and all to a cooling rack. Leave to cool down while you make the filling. (Don’t make too far ahead as it firms up quite quickly).

Prepare The Buttercream

  • Meanwhile, melt the second lot of butter, in a small cooking pot on the stove top on medium to high heat. Then turn the heat down to low-medium setting, letting it simmer and remember to stir occasionally. The butter will hiss & pop. If browning, reduce the heat further. Continue until pretty much silent and then strain through a sieve into a mixing bowl. There will be foamy fat residue sticking to the sides of the bowl and in the bottom of the sieve. See Photo 12. If after sieving, there are still pieces of foam/fats in your liquid, leave for 5 – 10 minutes for it to sink to the bottom and pour the liquid only, into a new bowl. Avery fine sieve is best
    Collage clarifieing the butter for the filling - photo 12.
  • Add in the salt. The mixture will sizzle again so be careful. This whole process is called ‘clarifying the butter’ and simply is separating the fat. It only takes about 10 minutes and makes for a really firm buttercream that sets perfectly for sandwich cookies and tastes great too. See Photo 12. Leave to sit for 5 minutes.
  • Add in the sieved icing/powdered sugar and mix by hand until all sugar is incorporated and a smooth paste is formed. See Photo 9. This will only take a minute, so no need to get the mixer out again. Leave till it cools down a little, and then add in the orange extract (if using, or orange zest), an ⅛ tsp at a time. Have a taste and add more is desired. See Photo 13. (My youngest son helping himself!)
    Powdered sugar added and then orange colouring - photo 13.
  • Next add a very small amount of the orange colouring paste by using a cocktail stick. I found it easiest to scrape onto the end of the mixing spoon. (That way you don’t stain your bowl). Then simply mix thoroughly and leave 30 seconds for the colour to develop, before adding another very small amount until you get a shade like in Photo 13 above. Best to always add small drops and get the exact shade you want, than add too much.

Assemble The Cookies

  • Begin by pairing up your cookies with as best matches as possible and keep any 'less perfect' ones for the bottoms. Lay out on baking/parchment paper, with all the 'bottom' cookies in a row and the 'tops' above.
  • Fit a piping bag with a medium round nozzle, or cut the tip, leaving a folded diameter of about ½cm (⅕"). Next fill the bag with the prepared buttercream filling. (If cutting, do so after filling with buttercream). Alternatively, you can use a small spoon and a butter knife or palette knife to apply. See Photo 13 below.
    Adding buttercream filling to a cookie and then placing 2nd on top - photo 13.
  • Pipe a line of the filling into the centre of the rectangular cookie, or pipe a circle for the square/circle/shaped cookies. If using a spoon, drop a small spoon's worth onto the cookie and spread a little. Don’t worry if you add too much – as you can scrape off the excess. Place the second/'top' cookie on top and squeeze together gently, letting the filling spread and fill & sandwich cookie. Let the filling almost come to the edges. If it comes out further, just use a small thin tool or the end of a small spoon and scrape along the edges, removing the excess. See the pics in Photo 14 below.
    Squeezing the cookies together and scraping the excess - photo 15.
  • You can also apply the filling to the 'bottom' cookie and leave to set a little, filling all the rest, and once finished, proceed to sandwich the cookies together. This results in less frosting coming out and no need to scrape the edges. For the piping method, see my Chocolate Filled Vanilla Sandwich Cookies.
  • Store in a tin or airtight container and these cookies will last at least 3 days.
    Stack of square cookies with round ones leaning against them.

Notes

Gluten Free Version – I have also made these cookies with Gluten Free flour,  in exactly the same way. Just be sure to add the Xanthan Gum (or Agar Agar), as listed in the ingredients. 
Close up of a bite out of the chocolate sandwich cookie with orange buttercream filling on a blue background.
Golden Syrup – for this particular recipe, you can also use maple syrup, honey or something similar. Click for where to buy Golden Syrup in the America & Canada.
Clarified Butter Filling –  The filling is made from clarified butter, (don’t worry, it’s super simple to make in about 10 minutes) and sets very nicely. So ideal for a sandwich cookie, with no filling squashing out.
Easter shaped chocolate cookies with cutters, mini easter eggs and flowers.
Vanilla Extract – learn how to easily make homemade Vanilla Extract.
Orange Food Colouring – like the brand Sugarflair, which is a paste.  You don’t use as  much as a gel or liquid colouring and the colours are very concentrated and vibrant.   Be careful, as it stains – so please wear gloves! 
Spring themed shaped cookies on patterned plate with pastel coloured decorated eggs.
Recipe Yield – hard to say how many it makes as it depends on what size & shape of cookie cutters you use.  But you will get at least 12 sandwich cookies.  My smaller round cutters & square cutters were  4cm/1.5″ wide.  The Easter themed cutter were larger.  There will also be more than enough buttercream filling for any size or quantity you make.
Mint Filling – I also made these using Shamrock cookie cutters, and filled with mint flavoured butter.  See below St Patrick’s Day Chocolate & Mint Oreo-style Sandwich Cookies.
Print Recipe
Collage of Easter & St Patrick’s Day Cookies

Chocolate & Orange Sandwich Cookies 

Stack of square cookies with round ones leaning against them.
Chocolate Orange Oreo-style Sandwich Cookies

Follow me on social media:


Thanks for reading

Happy Baking & Making

Happy Tummies & Memories!

Caro xx


My Privacy Policy

Chocolate orange sandwich cookie sin square, round and Easter shapes.
Chocolate Orange Oreo-style Sandwich Cookies


Leave some feedback if you like 🙂


Caroline’s Easy Baking Lessons

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Please Rate This Post/Recipe

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating