Reviewing Mary Berry’s Brandy Snaps Recipe
By Mrs D
Very much a common sweet treat consumed during Christmas time, I have been making these Brandy Snaps by Mary Berry, for several years. And with the popularity of the Great British Bake Off (Great British Baking Show), many American's & Canadians are eager to try out recipes they see on the show. So here is my review of Mary Berry's recipe, including anything I feel you need to know, to successfully make this tasty sweet treat.
Where To Find The Recipe
This is a review of Mary Berry’s Brandy Snaps recipe, taken from her book ‘Fast Cakes: Easy Bakes in Minutes’, (2019). You can also find the recipe on Mary Berry’s website, (go to Mary Berry’s Brandy Snaps recipe). I used to make these regularly, years ago and they also featured in this year’s GBBO. (The Great British Baking Show).
Brandy Snaps Ingredients
Before we move onto the recipe instructions just a few words about the ingredients.
The recipe only lists the ingredients in grams and ounces, with no cup measurements for US or Canadian bakers. And we know they LOVE Mary Berry and her recipes! I noticed too that the book version of the recipe used double the amount of ingredients. (More on that later).
Golden Syrup & Where To Buy
Point to note too, this recipe uses Golden Syrup. This should not be confused with Corn Syrup or Dark Corn Syrup. Caro often uses Golden Syrup and another popular British ingredient, Black Treacle, in her recipes, including her Gingerbread Cake.
The sweet recipe lesson no. 3, Gingerbread Recipe lists where to buy Golden Syrup in the states & Canada. So check that out above.
This recipe uses Demerara Sugar which is a light brown cane sugar with large crunchy crystals and a tasty caramel flavour. If you don’t have Demerara Sugar, then another option is to use Golden Castor Sugar or Dark Brown Sugar in its place.
In the case of this recipe, the sugar is dissolved, so it’s more about the taste coming from the sugar, rather than the size of the sugar. See my photo of UK Granulated sugar, compared to Demerara sugar, & the 3rd sugar is actually Dark Muscovado Sugar (not Dark brown Sugar). Dark Muscovado could even be used in this recipe. (In the UK, you can buy the Demerara & Dark Muscovado cheaper in Aldi).
For more on UK sugars, see my Differences Between UK & US Baking Ingredient article.
The recipe asks for you to line a baking tray/sheet with baking/parchment paper. No equipment list, or measurements given so I used a baking tray 13” x 9” (33x23cm), as you need a good size as the mixture spreads. That said, American ovens are much bigger than ours in the UK, so I would say this is actually about the size of a ¼ Sheet Pan.
The Recipe Process & Instructions
The recipe asks for you to add the butter, sugar and syrup into a heavy based saucepan. It can be a non-stick pot, as you are not going to heat the mixture to a high temperature like you do when making caramel. You need to make sure you heat it over a gentle heat which takes about 15 minutes, making sure the sugar and butter have dissolved completely. You have to remove the pan from the heat and let the mixture cool for 2-3 minutes before adding the sifted flour, ground ginger and lemon juice. Stir it really well, and leave to cool for about 10 minutes.
It goes on to say to place a teaspoonful of the mixture onto a large baking sheet. I left 4” (10cm) in-between them as they spread a lot when cooking. Just like the recipe said, I only did four at a time, and this is because you have to be so quick when they have baked as the mixture quickly hardens. They say to bake for 10-15 & mine took 12 mins. They should be golden brown and lacy in appearance.
The baked mixture needs to be just firm enough to remove, but pliable enough to shape. Use cooking spatula to gently lift them off the paper and then mould them round the end of a wooden spoon or bottom of a glass. If the mixture in the pan becomes too hard you can roll a teaspoon worth, into a small ball and put on the baking tray/sheet and slightly flatten it with your fingers.
I used 2 long handled greased wooden spoons so I could do the four all at one, but if they started to harden you could quickly place them back in the oven for a minute so you will be able to mould it easily. With the bandy snap basket, I greased the bottom of a glass and moulded the brandy snap over the bottom and fluted them with my fingers. When they have cooled and hardened, I gently remove them from the wooden spoon and put them on a cooling tray along with the baskets. I left mine for 10 mins as they harden quickly.
What I Thought Of The Recipe
I was very pleased with the final result, and taste. But I felt there was a lot missed off the recipe. No American or Canadian measurements were given nor what size baking tray/sheet to use.
On comparing this book version of the recipe, to what is listed on Mary Berry’s website, there were several differences. The on-line version is coming from her other book – Baking Bible.
The first noticeable difference was the quantity of ingredients called for. The online version used half the ingredients, so would make half the number of Brandy Snaps.
How Much Does It Yield?
Which leads me on to the quantity it yields. The book recipe, states 30 Brandy Snaps. I can get 14 Brandy Snaps and 4 of the bowl/basket style. But if you were to make all as the traditional Brandy snap tube shape, I would imagine you wouldn’t get any more than 22. So, quite short of the 30 the book states. Now obviously the bigger you make them, the less you get. But, the recipe, in the book or online, doesn’t say what size to make the disc of batter.
But the differences between the book and online version, don’t stop there. There were more than a dozen I counted. Many including useful information and tips. So rather than me list them here, I suggest you refer to both recipes before making these Brandy Snaps. And it was the online version had more information.
Another way to do the baskets is to mould them over an orange which I may try next time only found this when looking at another recipe.
The Brandy Snaps will keep for a week in an airtight tin.
SIGN UP FOR MY NEWSLETTER – I would love it so much if you could sign up for my newsletter. I will send out monthly emails, showing the latest recipes and articles, and latest info. Being a site without ads, building a following, is even more important and will keep it up and running and for free to everyone. Occasionally there will be the odd seasonal emails, but is really a means of reaching you, if you are not already in one of the Facebook groups I admin. Please note too, that these email addresses are not shared or sold onto another party. Thanks so much Caro xxx
Based on the taste and if you use the online version, in addition to the book recipe, I would rate this recipe a 7/10.
Be sure to check out Caro’s conversions of the ingredients into cup measurements. She hand-measures all these, as Google is often inaccurate or inconsistent. For more conversions, see her Conversion Of UK & US Common Baking Ingredients article with a handy table.
|BOOK AMOUNT LISTED||CUP CONVERSION|
|100g, 4 oz Butter, unsalted||1 cup less 1 tbsp|
|100g, 4 oz Demerara Sugar||Level 1/2 cup|
|100g, 4 oz Golden Syrup||1/3 cup, 3 1/2 fl oz|
|100g, 4 oz Plain Flour||3/4 cup All Purpose Flour|
|Oven: 180c/Fan Oven 160c/Gas 4||350f|
|Tray used: 33cm x 23cm||13” x 9”, 1/4 Sheet Pan|
Please see the sharing options or even printing, at the right/bottom of your screen (bottom of your screen for mobiles, and down the right-hand side on computers). You can even pin this to your own Pinterest page. You could also leave some feedback if you like.
Follow me on social media:
Thanks for reading
Happy Baking & Making
Happy Tummies & Memories!
Caro & Diana xx
Leave some feedback if you like:)