| | |

Oma Messer’s Buttermilk Biscuits – Passing Down Recipes Through The Generations

Overhead shot of wooden dinner table buttermilk biscuits cooling on rack, 2 served and baking things with title.
Oma Messer's Buttermilk Biscuits is a recipe that has been passed down through at least 4 generations & by posting online, I hope it will be preserved so that it can continue to pass down through even more families.

Oma Messer’s Buttermilk Biscuits

Passing Down Recipes Through The Generations

2 American buttermilk biscuits on a plate with measuring cups and oven mit to the sides.

Old Heritage Recipes

On my old website, I featured 2 old recipes that were kindly shared with me. The last was carried down the generations of my friend’s family, for nearly 100 years and I ran a ‘Bake-together’ last Christmas, as a way of keeping that traditional British Christmas Cake recipe going for many more years to come.

Buttermilk Biscuit Day

And since it’s Buttermilk Biscuit Day on 14th May 2021, (American biscuits, not to be confused with our UK cookie-biscuits), I thought it fitting to post a recipe for those on the site. I like the site to have recipes from different countries and cultures, but make sure they are traditional and authentic.

So for that task, the internet is not always your friend. Old recipe books and better still, very old family recipes are a much better bet. So via my baking friends who live in the states and Canada, I decided upon approaching Angelgale. She is one of the lovely admins of The Pioneer Woman Facebook group that I have belonged to since I first started the website. Through that group, I have made dozens of friends, who I genuinely would love to go visit if we are ever allowed international travel again (!!)

History Of The Recipe

Anyway, Angelgale is also a great cook and baker, and often shares her family’s recipes in group, so she was an obvious choice to ask for a good recipe. Thankfully she too encouraged the idea of sharing old recipes, and shared with me not only the recipe, but tips and some information on the history of the recipe. This is what she shared with me:

“This recipe goes back to my Urgroßmutter (great grandmother) who was a Master Baker by trade. My Oma Messer (grandmother) was also a Master Baker & she grew up helping my Urgroßmutter bake for the village of Eschen. (Liechtenstein, southwest of Central Europe). My Opa (grandfather) defected from Hitler and came to America. My grandparents then settled in the German town of Schulenburg, Texas. My Oma (grandmother) passed this down to my mom and my mom to myself & through our family.”

Close shot of 2 golden well risen buttermilk biscuits on a plate.

US Biscuit Or UK Scone?

For us in the UK American/Canadian biscuits, look kind of like our British Scones. Not to get in a debate, but although ingredients might be the same, the proportion of the ingredients, for most of these recipes, differs considerably, leading to a different texture of the bake.

That aside, different countries and different areas within those countries, coupled with recipes often being shared by word of mouth, variations occur and recipes evolve. Prime example being this Oma Messer recipe, that has it’s origins in Central Europe.

ANgled shot of 2 butermilk biscuits, some cooling and a flour sifter.

What To Eat With Biscuits?

Now for us in the UK, Classic Scones are usually eaten with something sweet, such as cream and jam, as a treat (although there are cheese savoury scones too). US biscuits however, are known for being paired with ‘gravy’. Not the Bisto type gravy we have, but more a combination of sausage meat and a creamy meaty gravy.

And this is where biscuits differ from our scones. The biscuits have a slightly firmer texture, and so pair well with sauces, more so than say bread, which wouldn’t hold it’s shape well for example.

I am reliably informed too that biscuits can be used as a mini sandwich vessel for breakfast foods, such as egg and meat.

Like UK scones, these biscuits don’t contain sugar, so go well too with the likes of jams and jelly’s. Angelgale’s family often enjoy them with homemade jam, which is no doubt something that has been occurring in her family, for generations too.

6 golden baked buttermilk biscuits on a white plate.

How Was The Recipe?

But enough about the background of this bake, how did I get on making them? Well, like our scones, I was careful to not twist the cutter, and chose to just spread the dough out gently with my hands, as it doesn’t make a big batch (so ideal for smaller households). You could of course easily double the recipe and even freeze them if needed.

They were very straight forward to make, and I used my pastry blender (pastry cutter), just as Angelgale had advised, but I didn’t need quite all the buttermilk. And that’s just because different flour, different ways and places it’s milled, determines a different amount of liquid that it will absorb. It makes for a nice soft dough, that is easy to cut out and unlike our scones, you don’t put an egg-wash on top of them before baking, but rather melted butter once out of the oven.

A little note too on the flour. Angelgale advised that she believed the key was the White Lily Self-rising flour. Now I can’t get that brand in the UK, but did a little research and found that that particular flour is a softer flour and has a slightly lower protein content than plain/All Purpose flour. This will help achieve a more tender crumb, so to take that into account, and because UK self-raising has a touch more baking powder in it than US self-rising, I used a little less of my flour and substituted a couple of table spoons of cornflour/starch. This was to reduce the protein content and raising agent slightly.

The Baked Biscuits

I am pleased to say, they baked off nicely (I hope so anyway), with what I would consider a good golden colour and rise. I do remember being told that biscuits can be quite pale in comparison to our scones, but I had a photo of Angelgale’s biscuits to go by, and I have always said, colour means flavour 🙂 Just like scones, the ones you cut out from the scraps, don’t produce as nice or pretty a shape, but they don’t taste any different, so a win.

2 golden bittermilk AMerican biscuits served with title.

How They Tasted

We tried them with jam, and also we had some for dipping along side our meal. It was a Turkish meal I learned to make because my husband is from Turkey. And they are a country of bread lovers, and have with every meal. So once we get back over there, I will be sharing this quick bread recipe with them, as I am sure they will love it and the ease of making these.

So thank you Angelgale, and to your mother, grandmother and great grandmother, for passing along this recipe, which I will share on the website, and wherever I go. Let’s keep this recipe going!!! 🙂

Oma Messer’s Buttermilk Biscuits

Makes 7 – 8 Biscuits


  • Measuring cups or scales
  • Measuring spoon (optional)
  • Pastry blender/Cutter or 2 Butter Knives
  • Measuring jug (optional)
  • Medium mixing bowl
  • Spoon or spatula
  • Fork
  • Flour for dusting
  • Cookie cutter (about 2″ or 5cm diameter)
  • Baking/Parchment paper
  • Timer
  • Cooling rack
  • Pastry brush


  • 2 cups White Lily Self-Rising Flour (250g, 8.75oz) 
  • (I used 235g Self-Raising + 2 tbsp (15g) Cornflour)
  • ¼ cup Crisco (51g, 1.75 oz)
  • (I used 51g Vegetable Shortening -Trex brand)
  • ¾ cup buttermilk  (180ml, 6 fl oz)
  • (If no buttermilk, add 2 1/4 tsp vinegar or lemon juice to milk & leave 10 minutes).
  • For topping –
  • 2 tablespoons butter, melted (30g, 1 oz)

Overhead photo of farmstyle wooden table with buttermilk in jugs, butterballs in cheese cloth draiining and test 'Benefits of homemade buttermilk & butter'.

Homemade Buttermilk & Butter

Buttermilk biscuits is an ideal opportunity to use your homemade buttermilk or even use the butter too.

Make your own butter and buttermilk with double/heavy cream. Look out for the cream when on reduction and about to go past its best before date. So easy to make with a mason jar or stand-mixer, this will save you money. Use up the milk as normal and freeze the butter in portions to last even longer. Read my guide to Homemade Buttermilk & Butter for how to.


Glass Pyrex bowl of flour and cubed butter - photo 1.

1.Begin by heating your oven to 475°f/245c/225c Fan Oven/ Gas Mark 9.

2.Prepare a baking tray/sheet with some baking/parchment paper.

3.Next measure out your flour but be sure to read the notes carefully in the ingredients.

4.Then add in the vegetable shortening (Crisco/Trex). I roughly cut mine into small pieces just to make the process easier. See Photo 1.

Cloase shot of flour after using a pastry blender - photo 2.

5. Give the shortening a quick mix through just to coat it in flour, before using a pastry blender/cutter to breakdown the mixture to a consistency resembling breadcrumbs (or peas size pieces). If you haven’t used a pastry blender before, just push down on the mixture, scraping the bottom of the bowl, and perform a rotating left and right motion. Repeat this all over the mixture, clearing out any mixture that inevitably get’s stuck in the blender. Alternatively, use 2 butter knives for this ‘cutting-in’ technique. See Photo 2.

Collage of made buttermilk and adding to dry ingredients - photo 3.

6. Once in small pieces, gradually add in the buttermilk. (If you don’t have buttermilk, add 2 1/4 tsp vinegar or lemon juice to the milk and leave for at least 10 minutes. It will look like off milk, but it will be fine I promise. It’s not actual buttermilk, but replicates the acidic level that real buttermilk has to benefit the recipe). See Photo 3.

7. Stir in the milk gradually with a fork, letting the flour take on as much moisture as possible before adding in more small amounts. You want to add enough to make the dough manageable. See more on that above. I didn’t need all the milk, but you might, or even a touch more.

Collage of forming the biscuit dough ainto a disc - photo 4.

8. Turn the dough out, onto a lightly floured surface (I use baking/parchment paper for things like this, and re-use the paper. Less clean up too 😉 See Photo 4.

9.Knead gently 5 to 6 times, just until a smooth dough is formed. (Over-handling this type of dough can impair the rise and make for a tougher bake)

Collage of dough and cutting out the biscuits - photo 5.

10. Roll dough out to a thickness of 3/4- 1″ (2 -2.5cm)

11. Then cut out biscuits using a floured 2-inch (5cm) biscuit (cookie) cutter. Place on the prepared baking sheet/tray, about 1-inch (2.5cm) apart. (For softer biscuits, Angelgale advises arranging so that edges almost touch.) See Photos 5 & 6.

Collage of cut out biscuits on tray and showing the structure pre baking - photo 6.

12.Gently and minimally, knead the excess dough and cut out as many more biscuits as you can get.

13. Now bake 8 to 10 minutes or until golden brown and well risen. Remove from oven and brush with butter, if desired. See Photo 7.

Here’s my biscuits below, baked off and with butter brushed on top.

Golden baked American biscuits cooling on rack - photo 7.

Join My Facebook Group

Why not also join my Facebook group – Easy Online Baking Lessons, dedicated to this baking lessons website, as well as providing one-on-one support with myself & my team? Be sure to answer all security questions when requesting to join. Click to join the group.

Share The Love

Please see the sharing options or even printing, at the right/bottom of your screen (bottom of your screen for mobiles, and down the right-hand side on computers). You can even pin this to your own Pinterest page. Alternatively, you can download this article, see below. You could also leave some feedback if you like. If you try the recipe, please remember some pics, and message me or tag me in social media – would love seeing them 🙂

Click the ‘Download’ button below, to save to your phone or computer.

DIFFICULTY LEVEL: super simple

Rating: 1 out of 5.

Follow me on social media:

Thanks for reading

Happy Learning & Baking!

Caro xx

Caroline’s Easy Baking Lessons

Leave some feedback if you like 🙂

My Privacy Policy

Caroline’s Easy Baking Lessons
Oma messer’s Buttermilk Biscuits
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Please Rate This Post/Recipe

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *